Homemade Thick and Creamy Yogurt: Just Milk, a Spoonful of Starter and One Quiet Night

How to Make Homemade Yogurt

  1. Heat the milk. Pour the milk into the heavy pot. If using milk powder, whisk it in now. Heat over medium-low, stirring often so the bottom does not scorch, until the milk reaches 180°F. You will see small bubbles at the edges and steam rising. This takes about 15 to 20 minutes.
  2. Hold it briefly. Keep the milk near 180°F for 5 minutes, stirring. This step helps the yogurt set thicker.
  3. Cool to warm. Take the pot off the heat and let the milk cool to 110°F to 115°F, about 30 to 45 minutes. To speed things up, set the pot in a sink of cold water and stir.
  4. Temper the starter. In a small bowl, whisk the 2 tablespoons of yogurt with about ½ cup of the warm milk until smooth.
  5. Add the starter. Pour the mixture back into the pot and stir gently. Add the cream now, if using.
  6. Keep it cozy. Cover the pot with its lid and wrap it in a thick towel. Place it in the oven with the oven turned off and only the oven light on.
  7. Let it set. Leave it undisturbed for 8 to 12 hours, or overnight. Do not stir or shake it. After 8 hours, check: the yogurt should be set like a soft custard and pull away from the side when you tilt the pot.
  8. Chill. Refrigerate the yogurt for at least 4 hours. It will thicken further as it chills.
  9. Strain for thick yogurt. Line a strainer with a double layer of cheesecloth and set it over a bowl. Spoon in the chilled yogurt and refrigerate for 1 to 3 hours, until it is as thick as you like.
  10. Whisk and serve. Whisk the yogurt briefly for a silky, smooth texture, then serve with berries, granola and honey.

Tips for Success

  • Use a thermometer. Too hot, and the cultures die. Too cool, and they work slowly. Between 110°F and 115°F is just right.
  • Do not disturb it while it sets. Moving the pot can keep it from firming up.
  • Longer means tangier. Eight hours gives a mild yogurt; 12 hours gives a pleasantly tart one.
  • Save the whey. The yellowish liquid from straining is wonderful in pancake batter, bread dough or smoothies.

Variations

For vanilla yogurt, stir 1 teaspoon of vanilla extract and 2 tablespoons of honey into the finished yogurt.

For labneh, a Middle Eastern yogurt cheese, stir ½ teaspoon of salt into the yogurt and strain it overnight until very thick. Serve drizzled with olive oil.

For a fruit swirl, gently fold in a few spoonfuls of berry jam right before serving.

How to Store Homemade Yogurt

Keep the yogurt in clean, covered glass jars in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks. A little liquid may collect on top; simply stir it back in or pour it off. Remember to save 2 tablespoons as the starter for your next batch within 7 days, while the cultures are strongest.

Nutrition Information

One cup of plain whole-milk yogurt provides roughly 150 to 170 calories, and strained yogurt about 200 to 230 calories per cup, before toppings. These numbers are approximate.

Final Thoughts

Making yogurt at home connects you to generations of women who kept a warm jar on the counter and a little starter saved for next week. It costs pennies, it tastes wonderful and it makes you feel quietly proud every single morning.

Start a batch tonight. Tomorrow, breakfast will be something you made with your own hands.

With love, from Grandma's kitchen ❤️

Hungry for more? Grandma has many more recipes waiting…

Discover Another Recipe