Homemade Thick and Creamy Yogurt: Just Milk, a Spoonful of Starter and One Quiet Night
Ingredients for Homemade Yogurt
This recipe makes about 2 quarts of regular yogurt, or about 1 quart of thick strained yogurt.
For the yogurt
- ½ gallon whole milk: 8 cups. Whole milk gives the creamiest, richest result.
- 2 tablespoons plain yogurt with live and active cultures: your starter. It must be plain and unsweetened.
Optional extras
- ½ cup nonfat dry milk powder: whisked into the cold milk, for a thicker yogurt without straining.
- 2 tablespoons heavy cream: for an extra rich, velvety batch.
For serving
- Fresh berries: raspberries, blueberries or sliced strawberries.
- Granola or toasted nuts: for crunch.
- Honey or maple syrup: a drizzle to taste.
Equipment
- A heavy pot with a lid: about 4 quarts.
- A kitchen thermometer: it takes the guesswork out.
- A fine strainer and cheesecloth or a clean thin kitchen towel: only if you want thick yogurt.
Choosing Your Milk and Starter
Read the starter label carefully. In the dairy aisle of any US supermarket, look for plain yogurt that says "live and active cultures" on the container. Choose one you love the taste of, because your homemade yogurt will taste similar. Avoid vanilla or flavored yogurts, and avoid anything with added gelatin or thickeners.
Whole milk is best, but 2% works too; the yogurt will simply be a little thinner. Regular pasteurized milk is perfect. Try to avoid "ultra-pasteurized" milk the first time, as some cooks find it sets less reliably. Lactose-free milk also works well and makes a mild, slightly sweet yogurt.
Once you have made your first batch, save 2 tablespoons of it to start the next one. Many families keep the same yogurt going for months.